Sunday, 30 January 2022

Where the Mind Is Without Fear written by Rabindranath Tagore-Explanation of the Poem

 Where the Mind Is Without Fear written by Rabindranath Tagore

 

About the Poet

Rabindra Nath Tagore is a well-known poet and writer of India. He was awarded the Nobel Prize for his collection of poems under the title ‘Gitanjali’. The present poem appeared in that collection of poems. The poet had written this poem in Bengali, but later he himself translated this poem into English.

About the Poem

Tagore wrote this poem when India was under British rule. People were hopeful in those days that sooner or later, their country was going to be liberated from the slavery of the British. Tagore was also cherishing the hope of freedom. So he wrote this poem in which he made prayer to God to grant his country the real type of freedom. By reading this poem, we come to know what type of freedom Tagore wished to get for his country.

Text of the Poem

 

Where the Mind id without Fear

Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high
Where knowledge is free
Where the world has not been broken up into fragments
By narrow domestic walls
Where words come out from the depth of truth

 

Where tireless striving stretches its arms towards perfection
Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way
Into the dreary desert sand of dead habit
Where the mind is led forward by thee
Into ever-widening thought and action
Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake

Line-to-line Explanation of the Poem
(Lines 1 to 4)

Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high
Where knowledge is free
Where the world has not been broken up into fragments
By narrow domestic walls
Where words come out from the depth of truth

 

Word-meanings: 1. Held-kept 2. Fragments-pieces 3. Narrow domestic walls: Usually when there is division in a house, small walls are erected (built) to show separation in a family. But here in the poem, the poet thinks of his country as a family. He hopes that no walls should be built to separate one human being from the other. In a way the poet does want that his countrymen should be divided on the basis of caste, religion, culture, and dogmas.

4. ‘words come out from the depth of truth’: The poet wishes that his countrymen should be truthful. They should not become hypocrites. Whatever they think and do must come out of the depth of their hearts. It should be real and genuine.
Explanation: The poet imagines an ideal situation. He wishes that his countrymen should be bold and courageous. They should not have any fear in their minds. They should be able to hold their heads high with the honour. In the next line, the poet wishes that in his country knowledge should be free. It should not be the prerogative (special right) of the few. The light of knowledge should spread everywhere. Every child of the country should have the right to education. Such is Tagore’s concept of education.

 

‘Where the world has not been broken up into fragments
By narrow domestic walls’

Tagore not only thinks of his own country India, it seems that he thinks of the whole world also (Vasudevo Kutumbhkam). He thinks of the whole world as a family which should not be divided into fragments (pieces). It happens when there is division into a family. Small domestic walls are built within the small house. Thus the unity of the family is destroyed.

But Tagore means to say that his country and even the whole world should not be divided on the basis of nationalities, languages, cultural differences, castes and religions.

‘Where words come out from the depth of truth’

In the above line, the poet wishes that his countrymen should be honest and truthful. He prays to God that his countrymen should be simple and straightforward. They should not show hypocrisy neither in their words nor in deeds. What they do should do or speak should come out of their hearts. It means they should be truthful and outspoken in words and deeds. The poet indeed imagines of an ideal situation in his country where no evil prevails.

 

Lines 5-8:

Where tireless striving stretches its arms towards perfection
Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way
Into the dreary desert sand of dead habit
Where the mind is led forward by thee
Into ever-widening thought and action
Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake
Word-meanings: 1.Tireless: without feeling tired 2. Striving: struggle

3. Clear stream of reasoning: The poet thinks of the mind in which the flow of thoughts is very clear 4. Dreary: dry 5. Thee: you 6. Dead habit: outdated customs and dogmas 7. Heaven of freedom: a country becomes a heaven of freedom when all the people respect one another’s freedom and rights.

 

Explanation: The poet makes a prayer to God that his country should be free in the real sense of the word. His countrymen should not be tired of struggling to achieve perfection in their work. Before doing anything the reasoning powers should guide them. They should not be swayed by their emotions while doing their actions.

A clear stream of well-reasoned thoughts should flow in their minds. Such thoughts should not be overpowered by the overflow of emotions that are related to their bad habits and old customs.

The poet also prays that the minds of his people should ever be widening. He means to say that his countrymen should always try to increase their knowledge.

Rabindranath Tagore compares well-reasoned thoughts to a stream full of clear water. He has also compared old habits, narrow-mindedness and dogmas to the sand that is spread in a vast dry desert. If, by any means, a stream of water is made to pass through such a desert, it would get lost into the dry sand. In that case, it will be a sheer wastage of valuable water. In the same way, well-reasoned thoughts also go waste if they are overpowered by bad habits, dogmas and narrow-mindedness.

So the poet prays to God that his countrymen should always have well-reasoned thoughts. There should not be any place for bad habits in their minds.

After that, the poet again prays to God that his countrymen’s minds should always keep on broadening. They should always accept new ideas to develop their mind and personalities. There should be appropriate coordination between their thoughts and actions. Every human being in his country should enjoy the freedom of thought.

If all the above wishes of the poet are granted by God, then, his country would really become a ‘heaven of freedom’.

 

Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake

Lastly, the poet seems to pray to God to awaken the inner-being (deep insight) of his countrymen so that they should be able to differentiate between good and evil, right and wrong, and friend and foe.

 

Stanzas for Comprehensions:

Stanza 1.

Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high
Where knowledge is free
Where the world has not been broken up into fragments
By narrow domestic walls
Reference to the Context: The above lines have been taken from the poem ‘Where the Mind is without fear’ written by Rabindranath Tagore. In this poem, the poet thinks of an ideal situation. He prays to God that his country should be free in the real sense of the word. His countrymen should not be slaves to bad habits, narrow-mindedness, dogmas.

Explanation: The poet imagines an ideal situation. He wishes that his countrymen should be bold and courageous. They should not have any fear in their minds. They should be able to hold their heads high with the honour. In the next line, the poet wishes that in his country knowledge should be free. It should not be the prerogative (special right) of the few. The light of knowledge should spread everywhere. Every child of the country should have the right to education. Such is Tagore’s concept of education. Tagore not only thinks of his own country India, it seems that he thinks of the whole world also (Vasudevo Kutumbhkam). He thinks of the whole world as a family which should not be divided into fragments (pieces). It happens when there is a division into a family. Small domestic walls are built within the small house. Thus the unity of the family is destroyed.

But Tagore means to say that his country and even the whole world should not be divided on the basis of nationalities, languages, cultural differences, castes, and religions.

Stanza 2

Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way
Into the dreary desert sand of dead habit
Where the mind is led forward by thee
Into ever-widening thought and action
Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake
Reference to the Context: The above lines have been taken from the poem ‘Where the Mind is without fear’ written by Rabindranath Tagore. In this poem, the poet thinks of an ideal situation. He prays to God that his country should be free in the real sense of the word. His countrymen should not be slaves to bad habits, narrow-mindedness, dogmas. They should live in harmony and unity. His country should be real heaven in which his countrymen will enjoy their freedom.

 

Explanation: The poet makes a prayer to God that his country should be free in the real sense of the word. Before doing anything the reasoning powers should guide them. They should not be swayed by their emotions while doing their actions.

A clear stream of well-reasoned thoughts should flow in their minds. Such thoughts should not be overpowered by the overflow of emotions that are related to their bad habits and old customs.

The poet also prays that the minds of his people should ever be widening. He means to say that his countrymen should always try to increase their knowledge.

Rabindranath Tagore compares well-reasoned thoughts to a stream full of clear water. He has also compared old habits, narrow-mindedness, and dogmas to the sand that is spread in a vast dry desert. If, by any means, a stream of water is made to pass through such a desert, it would get lost into the dry sand. In that case, it will be sheer wastage of valuable water. In the same way, well-reasoned thoughts also go waste if they are overpowered my bad habits, dogmas and narrow-mindedness.

So the poet prays to God that his countrymen should always have well-reasoned thoughts. There should not be any place for bad habits in their minds.

After that, the poet again prays to God that his countrymen’s minds should always keep on broadening. They should always accept new ideas to develop their mind and personalities. There should be appropriate coordination between their thoughts and actions. Every human being in his country should enjoy freedom of thought. Then and only then his country can be called a Heaven of freedom. They should always remain awakened.

 

 

Wide gap between the reality of contemporary India and Tagore's concept of India-Rabindranath Tagore-Where the Mind is without Fear

 Q3. Comment on the wide gap between the reality of contemporary India and Tagore's concept of India.

Ans. In the poem, ‘Where the Mind is without Fear;, the poet Rabindranath Tagore cherishes ideal conditions for his country. He thinks that political and economic freedoms are useless if the people are not mentally free. Our mind should not be a slave to any dogmas, narrow-mindedness, and social or moral evil. He thinks of a country where people are fearless, courageous, and brave. There should not be any barrier that divides his countrymen on the basis of colour, caste, and creed.  His countrymen should be free to increase their knowledge. Education in his country should be free for all. The people of his country should be broad-minded, honest, and generous in nature.  They should be true to their word actions and thoughts.  If all these qualities are imbibed into the personality of the people, then, his country would really become a heaven of freedom on the earth.

But in reality, we find quite an opposite picture. The people of our country are still slaves to so many evils. They are not mentally strong. Fear still prevails in the minds of people. Dogmas, narrow-mindedness, and social or moral evil is still present. Discrimination on the basis of colour, caste, and religion is present in the minds of many people.

So there is a wide gap between the reality of contemporary India and Tagore's concept of India.

Write a note on Tagore’s concept of the ‘Heaven of freedom’-Where the Mind is without Fear-Rabindranath Tagore

 Q2. Write a note on Tagore’s concept of the ‘Heaven of freedom’.

Ans. According to common perception (view/opinion), heaven is a place where everything is in ideal condition. No evil is found there. It is a place where gods and goddesses are found.  Tagore also cherishes (takes pleasure in) the dream in which he wishes his country to become a place like heaven. So we may say that it is only possible when everything becomes ideal and human beings also behave as gods and goddesses do. For that, Tagore prays to God that his countrymen should adopt certain qualities that make them ideal beings. He thinks that political and economic freedoms are useless if the people are not mentally free.

Our mind should not be a slave to any dogmas, narrow-mindedness, and social or moral evil. He thinks of a country where people are fearless, courageous, and brave. There should not be any barrier that divides his countrymen on the basis of colour, caste, and creed.  His countrymen should be free to increase their knowledge. Education in his country should be free for all. The people of his country should be broad-minded, honest, and generous in nature.  They should be true to their word actions and thoughts.  If all these qualities are imbibed into the personality of the people, then, his country would really become a heaven of freedom on the earth.