Chapter
V – The Power Struggle and the Expulsion of Snowball
Notes
by Sheesh Pal Chauhan
Winter
on Animal Farm
As
winter arrives, life becomes more difficult. The animals continue their work
despite the cold, but food supplies are scarce. Meetings in the big barn still
take place every Sunday, where all decisions are debated and voted on. Snowball
and Napoleon are now openly in competition for leadership, each presenting his
own ideas and plans for the farm’s future.
Snowball’s
Committees and Education Plans
Snowball
takes the lead in trying to improve life on the farm through organization. He
forms committees such as the “Egg Production Committee” for hens and the “Clean
Tails League” for cows. Most of these projects fail, but his greatest success
lies in teaching the animals to read and write. Snowball simplifies the Seven
Commandments into the single phrase “Four legs good, two legs bad” so
that even the less intelligent animals can remember it.
Napoleon’s
Different Approach
Napoleon
is less interested in committees. He focuses on educating the young, believing
that shaping the minds of the next generation is most important. He takes nine
puppies away from their mothers, saying he will train them himself. The other
animals assume this is for education, but Napoleon keeps them out of sight, and
their purpose remains mysterious.
Growing
Disagreements
As
the meetings continue, the rivalry between Snowball and Napoleon becomes
sharper. They disagree on nearly every proposal. Snowball is an eloquent
speaker who uses persuasive arguments, while Napoleon is more reserved but
works behind the scenes to gather support. The animals often find it hard to
choose between them.
The
Windmill Proposal
Snowball
presents his most ambitious idea: building a windmill to generate electricity.
He argues that it will save labor, allowing the animals to have more leisure
time and live in greater comfort. Snowball describes how electricity could
power machines like threshers, ploughs, and chaff-cutters, making life much
easier.
Napoleon
strongly opposes the plan. He claims that the animals should focus on producing
food rather than wasting time on a complex project. The debates become heated,
and both leaders campaign vigorously to win support.
Napoleon’s
Counterattack
On
the day of the decisive vote, Snowball delivers a powerful speech in favour of
the windmill. Just as the animals are about to vote, Napoleon lets out a
strange, high-pitched whimper. Suddenly, nine enormous dogs burst into the
barn. These are the puppies Napoleon had secretly raised. Fierce and loyal,
they attack Snowball, who barely escapes through a hole in the hedge. Snowball
is driven off the farm and never seen again.
Napoleon
Takes Control
With
Snowball gone, Napoleon declares the end of Sunday meetings. Instead, decisions
will be made by a special committee of pigs, presided over by himself. He
claims this will save time and prevent confusion. The animals are uneasy about
losing their right to vote, but the fierce dogs surrounding Napoleon keep them
silent.
Squealer’s
Justification
Squealer
is sent to explain the changes. Using his usual persuasive style, he argues
that leadership is a heavy responsibility and that Napoleon is making
sacrifices for the good of all. He accuses Snowball of being a dangerous
troublemaker and hints that Snowball was a traitor all along. The animals are
confused, but the fear of the dogs and Squealer’s smooth words convince them to
accept Napoleon’s authority.
The
Windmill Decision Reversed
Strangely,
a few days after expelling Snowball, Napoleon announces that the windmill will
be built after all. Squealer explains this by saying that the idea was actually
Napoleon’s from the start, but that Snowball had tried to steal credit.
According to Squealer, Napoleon only pretended to oppose it to get rid of
Snowball, whose presence would have ruined the project.
Significance
of the Chapter
Chapter
V marks the end of democratic discussion on Animal Farm. Napoleon’s use of force to remove Snowball signals the rise of a
dictatorship. The dogs represent a loyal military force that ensures obedience,
while Squealer’s propaganda manipulates the animals into accepting false
narratives.
The
chapter also highlights a key theme: how those in power can twist the truth to
control the masses. Napoleon’s sudden support for the windmill shows his
political cunning—he takes credit for popular ideas while eliminating rivals.
The animals’ inability to question authority foreshadows further exploitation.
Foreshadowing
Future Events
With
Snowball gone, Napoleon’s unchecked power will allow him to reshape the farm’s
rules and rewrite history to his advantage. The building of the windmill, now
seen as Napoleon’s project, will become a central focus in the coming
chapters—bringing both hope and hardship to the animals.
Chapter
VI – Harder Work and Broken Promises
Increased
Workload for the Animals
By
the next spring and summer, the animals find themselves working harder than
ever before. The windmill project, championed by Napoleon, demands enormous
labour. Every Sunday, work is “voluntary,” but those who miss it lose half
their food ration—making it compulsory in reality.
They
face the challenge of breaking and transporting large stones to build the
windmill without the help of human tools or machinery. Rolling the stones up
the hill and breaking them into pieces requires great teamwork. Even Boxer, the
strongest animal, strains himself but remains motivated by his personal motto: “I
will work harder.”
Life
Becomes Tougher
While
the animals work tirelessly, they notice that their workload has increased
compared to the days before the Rebellion. Although the humans are gone,
comfort and leisure remain distant dreams. Still, they are encouraged by the
thought that they are working for their own benefit, not for human masters.
The
Question of Supplies
Some
necessary items for the windmill—like nails, iron, and certain tools—cannot be
produced on the farm. Napoleon announces a new policy: Animal Farm will engage
in limited trade with neighbouring farms to acquire these goods. The animals
are uneasy at first, remembering the original resolution against dealing with
humans, but Squealer convinces them that no such resolution ever existed—or
that they are misremembering it.
Dealing
with Humans
Napoleon
begins business dealings through Mr. Whymper, a human solicitor who visits the
farm every Monday. His visits help spread the idea that Animal Farm is
successful and thriving. The pigs start living in the farmhouse, claiming it is
necessary for their work as leaders. When the animals recall a rule against
animals sleeping in beds, Squealer explains that the Commandment actually
reads, “No animal shall sleep in a bed with sheets.” The pigs remove the
sheets, and the rule is declared intact.
The
Windmill Takes Shape
Through
the summer and into autumn, the windmill slowly rises. Progress is slow due to
the lack of proper tools, but the animals remain proud of their accomplishment.
Boxer pushes himself beyond his limits, waking earlier than the others to
contribute extra work. His dedication inspires the rest, though Clover worries
about his health.
A
Harsh Winter Approaches
By
late autumn, the animals are exhausted, and the weather grows colder. Then, a
violent storm strikes the farm. Trees are uprooted, fences blown down, and,
most disastrously, the windmill collapses into ruins. The animals are
devastated by the loss of their months of hard labour.
Blaming
Snowball
Napoleon
immediately blames Snowball for the destruction, claiming the traitor returned
under cover of night to sabotage the windmill. Squealer supports this
accusation, painting Snowball as a spy and enemy. The animals are told that
Snowball has sold himself to Frederick of Pinchfield Farm and is working with
humans to bring Animal Farm down.
Napoleon’s
Reaction
Napoleon
becomes more authoritarian, announcing new security measures. The animals are
ordered to rebuild the windmill, this time with walls twice as thick to
withstand any storm. Despite their exhaustion, the animals agree without
protest, convinced that Snowball’s treachery must be punished by their renewed
effort.
Propaganda
at Work
Squealer’s
speeches grow more aggressive, urging the animals to be vigilant against
Snowball’s supposed agents. Fear and suspicion spread across the farm. Even
though many animals privately doubt that Snowball could have caused the storm,
they do not dare voice their doubts.
Key
Themes in This Chapter
Manipulation
of the Truth: Napoleon alters the past and uses fear to control the animals.
The original rule about beds is changed, and Snowball is blamed for events he
did not cause.
Exploitation
of Labor: The animals work harder under their own rule than they ever did for
humans, showing that exploitation can come from within a society.
The
Role of Propaganda: Squealer’s twisting of facts keeps the animals loyal and
obedient, even against their own interests.
Foreshadowing
The
destruction of the windmill and Napoleon’s reaction signal a future of endless
labour cycles and shifting truths. The animals’ blind trust in leadership will
make it easy for Napoleon to tighten his control further.